Skip to publication summary
Peer-reviewed journal article · 2020 · Child fitness assessment

The effect of elbow position on the handgrip strength test in children: validity and reliability of TKK 5101 and DynX dynamometers

Stefan Kolimechkov · Jose Castro-Piñero · Lubomir Petrov · Albena Alexandrova

Pedagogy of Physical Culture and Sports, 24(5), 240–247 · DOI 10.15561/26649837.2020.0504

60 children30 boys and 30 girls
6–11 yearsprimary-school age range
2 positionsfull extension and 90° elbow flexion
2 devicesTKK 5101 and DynX dynamometers
STK SPORT research summary graphic comparing fully extended and 90-degree-flexed elbow positions during handgrip testing in children with two dynamometer designs
STK SPORT editorial illustration of the two elbow positions and dynamometer types examined in the study. This is not a figure reproduced from the paper.

A small change in test position can change the strength value.

Handgrip testing is quick, portable and commonly included in child fitness batteries. For the result to be useful, assessors need a standard protocol that produces maximal, repeatable values and allows fair comparison across settings.

This study compared two elbow positions with two dynamometers while also checking both instruments against known weights. It therefore addressed the child-testing protocol and the measurement quality of the devices.

Which elbow position is more appropriate for maximal handgrip testing in children, and how valid and reliable are the two dynamometers?
What the researchers did

A randomised comparison of position and device.

Sixty children aged 6–11 years completed repeated handgrip trials with the TKK 5101 Grip-D and DynX dynamometers at a London primary school.

The test hand, elbow position and dynamometer order were randomised. Each condition was performed twice, with recovery time between attempts and devices.

01 · Setup

Grip span and familiarisation

The TKK grip span was adjusted from each child’s hand size; the DynX used its second handle position. Children received standard instructions and held each squeeze for at least two seconds.

02 · Position comparison

Extended and flexed elbows

Each child completed right- and left-hand trials with the elbow fully extended and flexed to 90°. At least 60 seconds separated trials and at least five minutes separated devices.

03 · Measurement quality

Known-weight calibration

Validity and reliability were checked using 5–30 kg known weights in 5 kg increments, measured twice in random order. Agreement was evaluated with Bland–Altman analysis.

What the study found

Full elbow extension produced the higher values.

The extended-elbow position produced greater handgrip strength with both dynamometers, with a larger positional difference for the TKK device.

TKK 5101

About 11% higher with the elbow extended

Extended-elbow values exceeded 90°-flexed values by 1.61 kg on the right and 1.64 kg on the left (both p<0.001).

DynX

A smaller but significant positional difference

Extended-elbow values were 0.49 kg higher on the right (p=0.035) and 0.57 kg higher on the left (p=0.003), equivalent to approximately 3.6–4.3%.

Validity

TKK showed the closer agreement with known weights

The TKK bias was −0.20 kg and was not statistically significant. The DynX bias was −0.42 kg and statistically significant (p<0.001).

Reliability

Both devices were consistent on repeat testing

Repeat-measurement biases were small and non-significant: −0.07 kg for TKK and +0.10 kg for DynX, with narrow limits of agreement.

Interpretation and boundaries

Standardising elbow position strengthens child fitness assessment.

Within the tested protocol, full elbow extension was the most appropriate position for obtaining maximal handgrip values in children. The study also provides direct device-validation evidence in the strength range assessed.

What it may mean

Use and report a consistent protocol

Researchers, teachers and coaches can improve comparability by keeping the elbow position, dynamometer model, grip span and trial instructions consistent and reporting them clearly.

Important limitations

How far the findings reach

  • The sample came from one London primary school and included 60 children aged 6–11.
  • Only two elbow positions and two dynamometer models were examined, so device- and protocol-specific findings should not be generalised without testing.
What it does not establish

No universal diagnostic standard

  • The study does not show that one device is superior in every age group, population or testing setting.
  • It was not a training intervention and does not show that extending the elbow increases a child’s underlying strength.
Research source

Read and cite the paper.

Use the verified DOI record or read the open-access paper.

Formatted citation

Kolimechkov, S., Castro-Piñero, J., Petrov, L., & Alexandrova, A. (2020). The effect of elbow position on the handgrip strength test in children: Validity and reliability of TKK 5101 and DynX dynamometers. Pedagogy of Physical Culture and Sports, 24(5), 240–247. https://doi.org/10.15561/26649837.2020.0504