Skip to publication summary
Peer-reviewed review article · 2020 · Anthropometric assessment

The Body Mass Index: A Systematic Review

Stefan Kolimechkov · Lubomir Petrov

Journal of Exercise Physiology and Health, 3(2), 21–27

>50 sourcesinternational evidence and reference standards reviewed
Adultsfixed BMI categories support population-level interpretation
Childrenage- and sex-specific references are essential
BMI ≠ compositionthe index does not distinguish fat from muscle
STK SPORT research summary illustrating BMI calculation, adult thresholds, child and adolescent growth references, and the distinction between body mass index and body composition
A visual summary of the review’s comparison of BMI interpretation in adults, children and athletic populations. It is an STK SPORT editorial illustration, not a figure reproduced from the journal paper.

BMI is easy to calculate. Interpreting it well is the harder task.

Body mass index relates body mass to height and is used internationally to screen weight status. Its value lies in simplicity, comparability and extensive reference data. Yet interpretation depends on the person being assessed and the reference system applied.

This review brought together adult classifications, child and adolescent growth references, and the practical limits of BMI in athletic populations. Its central contribution is a clear framework for using a familiar index more appropriately.

Which BMI standards should be used for adults and growing children, and when should BMI be supported by other measurements?
What the researchers did

They compared international BMI standards and their practical interpretation.

The authors searched academic databases, reference lists and World Health Organization reports, then synthesised evidence for adults, children, adolescents and athletes.

This was an evidence synthesis. It did not recruit participants or test a new intervention.

  1. SearchAcademic databases, reference lists and WHO reports to February 2020
  2. SelectMore than 50 relevant English-language sources retained
  3. CompareAdult thresholds and child reference systems examined
  4. InterpretLimits and complementary measures considered for practice
01 · Adult assessment

Fixed classification thresholds

The review described BMI calculation and the World Health Organization categories commonly used to classify adult weight status.

02 · Growth

Children and adolescents

WHO, CDC and IOTF references were compared because BMI changes with growth and must be interpreted by age and sex.

03 · Athletic context

Body composition and proportions

The authors examined why muscularity and body proportions can affect BMI and discussed complementary anthropometric measures.

What the review found

BMI remains useful when the right reference and context are applied.

The calculation is consistent, but its interpretation must reflect age, sex, growth and body composition.

Adult assessment

Fixed thresholds provide a common framework

For adults, BMI is calculated as weight in kilograms divided by height in metres squared. WHO categories provide widely recognised thresholds for population screening and comparison.

Growth-sensitive assessment

Children require age- and sex-specific references

Because BMI changes during growth and differs between boys and girls, child and adolescent results should be interpreted using percentiles or Z-scores rather than adult cut-offs.

Reference systems

WHO, CDC and IOTF criteria are not interchangeable

The major international systems address the same assessment problem but use different populations, statistical methods and classification cut-offs. The selected reference should therefore be reported clearly.

Body composition

BMI cannot separate fat mass from muscle mass

Two people with the same BMI may have different body composition. This is especially relevant when evaluating muscular athletes or children engaged in intensive sport.

Better interpretation

Complementary measurements add useful context

The review recommended combining BMI with measures such as waist-to-height ratio, body-fat assessment, handgrip strength, arm circumference and upper-arm muscle area when a fuller profile is needed.

Interpretation and boundaries

A valuable screening index—strongest when used with the correct reference.

The paper clarifies how a familiar measure can support more responsible assessment across adult, paediatric and sporting contexts.

What it may mean

Use BMI as a structured starting point

BMI can support weight-status screening and longitudinal monitoring when practitioners use an age-appropriate standard, report the reference system and interpret the result alongside the person’s wider profile.

Important limitations

A focused synthesis rather than a pooled analysis

  • The search was limited to English-language material available up to February 2020.
  • The paper did not report a PRISMA flow diagram, formal risk-of-bias assessment or meta-analysis.
  • Differences between reference systems can change classification near category boundaries.
What it does not establish

BMI is not a direct measure of body fat

  • It does not diagnose health or disease on its own.
  • It does not distinguish fat, muscle or their distribution.
  • It should not be the sole body-composition assessment for athletes or growing children.
Research source

Read and cite the paper.

Read the complete article hosted on STK SPORT.

Formatted citation

Kolimechkov, S., & Petrov, L. (2020). The Body Mass Index: A Systematic Review. Journal of Exercise Physiology and Health, 3(2), 21–27.